---
title: "Do Eurasian Magpies recognise themselves in mirrors?"
description: "Two Eurasian Magpies showed the expected response in one mirror test. A later study did not reproduce the result."
canonical: https://animalchecklist.com/animal/eurasian-magpie/article
published: 2026-11-16T07:16:32.582Z
modified: 2026-11-16T07:16:32.582Z
lang: en
---

# Do Eurasian Magpies recognise themselves in mirrors?

Two Eurasian Magpies showed the expected response in one mirror test. A later study did not reproduce the result.

The evidence is mixed\. In one experiment, two Eurasian Magpies used a mirror in a way that suggested they noticed a mark on their own bodies\. A later study did not reproduce that result\. A bird pecking at its reflection is not showing the response those studies looked for\.

## What counts as a response?

In [the 2008 study](<https://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/journal.pbio.0060202>), Helmut Prior, Ariane Schwarz and Onur Güntürkün tested five hand\-raised adult magpies\. They compared a bright mark on the throat with a black mark that was hard to see against the feathers\. They also swapped the mirror for a flat plate that did not reflect\. The question was whether a bird would reach for the mark on its own throat more often when it could see the bright mark in the mirror\.

For two birds, Gerti and Goldie, a larger share of the movements toward their own bodies targeted the marked area when the bright mark and mirror were both present\. No bird pecked at the reflected mark\. Reaching toward its own throat is the relevant response\. The comparison without a mirror matters because a bird might respond to the feel of the mark\.

## What happened when researchers repeated the test?

[Manuel Soler and colleagues](<https://peraltasanchez.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/36-Soler-2020-JCompPsychol.pdf>) published a close repeat in 2020 with eight magpies caught in the wild\. Out of eight actions aimed at the mark, six occurred with cardboard in place of the mirror\. That is a count of actions, not a count of birds\. The later team did not find the pattern seen in the first study\.

The two groups differed in their experience with people and captivity\. The studies do not tell us why their results differed\. The first result is evidence from two individuals, and the second is a reason to be cautious about saying what the whole species can do\.

## Identify the bird by what you can see

![A black and white magpie in profile, with a white shoulder and a blue sheen on its folded wing\.](<https://animalchecklist.com/img/animals/eurasian-magpie/medium.jpg?v=09ebfd6a>)

The white shoulder and dark wing help identify this Eurasian Magpie\. The full length of the tail is not clear in this view\.

[Tero Linjama](<https://api.inaturalist.org/v1/users/terolinjama>), [CC0](<https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/>). [api\.inaturalist\.org](<https://api.inaturalist.org/v1/observations/290168999>).

The [British Trust for Ornithology](<https://www.bto.org/learn/about-birds/birdfacts/magpie>) describes the long tail and white wing patches\. In a short view, look for the tail and the pattern together\. The [Integrated Taxonomic Information System](<https://www.itis.gov/servlet/SingleRpt/SingleRpt?search_topic=TSN&search_value=179720>) lists this species as Pica pica, the Eurasian Magpie\. If you see one at a reflective window, identify it by its features rather than its reaction to the glass\. When you are confident, [mark it as seen on the Eurasian Magpie page](<https://animalchecklist.com/animal/eurasian-magpie>)\.
