---
title: "Common Frog or toad? Skin, spawn and tadpole clues"
description: "Compare Common Frogs and Common Toads in Britain. Look at several adult features, and learn why black tadpoles alone cannot settle the identification."
canonical: https://animalchecklist.com/animal/european-common-frog/article
published: 2026-11-20T07:16:02.771Z
modified: 2026-11-20T07:16:02.771Z
lang: en
---

# Common Frog or toad? Skin, spawn and tadpole clues

Compare Common Frogs and Common Toads in Britain. Look at several adult features, and learn why black tadpoles alone cannot settle the identification.

In Britain, compare the skin, hind legs and patch behind the eye\. Common Frogs have smooth skin and long back legs\. Common Toads have rough, warty skin and usually crawl\. Use the features together\. Colour alone is weak evidence, and freshly hatched black tadpoles can belong to either\.

This profile covers [Rana temporaria](<https://amphibiansoftheworld.amnh.org/Amphibia/Anura/Ranidae/Rana/Rana-temporaria>), which Animal Checklist calls European Common Frog and Grasfrosch in German\. The comparison species is [Bufo bufo](<https://amphibiansoftheworld.amnh.org/Amphibia/Anura/Bufonidae/Bufo/Bufo-bufo>), called Common Toad in British guides\. AMNH's Amphibian Species of the World treats both as species\. This is a British comparison, not a key to every European frog or toad\.

## Look at the skin and head together

[Froglife's adult identification guide](<https://www.froglife.org/info-advice/frequently-asked-questions/frogs-toads-identification/>) describes the Common Frog's smooth skin, long striped hind legs and dark patch behind the eye\. A side view can show the patch and leg markings together\. If plants hide the legs, that part of the comparison remains unavailable\.

The Common Toad has rough, warty skin, golden eyes and two raised glands behind the eyes\. It tends to crawl rather than make long jumps\. A movement tendency is a supporting clue\. Do not make an animal move to test it\.

A brown animal is not automatically a toad\. [Froglife's Common Frog account](<https://www.froglife.org/info-advice/amphibians-and-reptiles/common-frog-2/>) records colours beyond the familiar brown and green, including yellow, pink, red and black\. A colour description cannot replace a clear view of the other features\.

![A brown frog's head among pond plants, with a dark patch behind the visible eye\.](<https://inaturalist-open-data.s3.amazonaws.com/photos/690166208/medium.jpg>)

This European Common Frog is mostly hidden by pond plants\. The dark patch behind its eye is visible\. The view does not show the body or hind legs\.

[Sara Scorey](<https://api.inaturalist.org/v1/observations/377413290>), [CC0](<https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/>). [api\.inaturalist\.org](<https://api.inaturalist.org/v1/observations/377413290>).

## Clumps and strings tell different stories

In [Froglife's spawn guide](<https://www.froglife.org/info-advice/frequently-asked-questions/spawn-tadpoles-identification/>), frog eggs lie in jelly clumps\. Toad eggs form long strings, usually around underwater plants\. Newt eggs are separate, each wrapped in a submerged leaf\. The arrangement is a more useful first clue than the black dots inside the jelly\.

That distinction helps separate these groups in the guide's British setting\. It does not make every clump a confirmed Rana temporaria record across Europe\. A frog beside a clump also does not prove that it laid those eggs\. Keep the adult identification and the egg observation separate\.

## Why black tadpoles are not enough

Newly hatched Common Frog tadpoles are black too\. As they develop, they become mottled brown or bronze\. Common Toad tadpoles remain black and often gather in shoals\. The stage matters: a dark group immediately after hatching does not settle the frog\-or\-toad question\.

The identification problem also matters in research\. In a [2019 study](<https://scidar.kg.ac.rs/bitstream/123456789/8423/1/10.1163-15685381-00001193.pdf>), Ilić and colleagues compared Common Frog, Agile Frog and Common Toad tadpoles\. They raised them from egg clutches collected in Serbia, then measured body and tail shapes from magnified photographs\.

The team examined 120 preserved specimens, 40 from each species, at early developmental stages\. Additional tadpoles from each aquarium supplied DNA checks\. The study used detailed measurements under controlled conditions\. It does not provide an identification success rate for a glance into a garden pond\.

## Leave the animal where it is

[Froglife advises against moving spawn or tadpoles between ponds](<https://www.froglife.org/info-advice/frequently-asked-questions/spawn-tadpoles-larvae/>)\. Moving them can also carry disease or invasive plants\. Watch from the bank and leave the animals and spawn in place\. Do not collect a tadpole or handle a frog to obtain a better view\.

When the features support the species, use [Mark as seen on the European Common Frog page](<https://animalchecklist.com/animal/european-common-frog>)\. The catalogue's [European Toad entry](<https://animalchecklist.com/animal/european-toad>) covers Bufo bufo\. If you only saw a black tadpole or a hidden shape, leave the species unchecked until you have enough evidence\.
